Or, if one inverts the question, why do people give angpows in the first place? Sure it's nice to receive angpows, but the custom would never have evolved unless the giver did not reap some benefit, even if said benefit is intangible. As far as I can tell, there are a few possible reasons:
- Signalling one's wealth. This is quite important to save face - Chinese culture seems to have an obsession with appearing prosperous, even if the creditors are at the door. Not that this is necessarily a bad thing, in Chinese society.
- Genuine altruism. For many children a few decades ago, the money received at Chinese New Year represents a whole year's worth of pocket money. Nowadays with inflation and different levels of consumer spending this is no longer the case of course, but that simply means that one needs to give larger angpows...
- Making sweet nothings mean something. If one just wishes relatives and friends Happy New Year, that can easily be insincere. Adding some money actually reinforces the greeting and says "Hey! I really feel you deserve a Happy New Year, to the extent I'll fund some of your happiness!"
- Signalling respect, or the quid pro quo. Giving money to people who, or are connected to people who, have done something for you. It's a simple thank you gesture, although in Chinese culture, money doesn't quite repay favours - it's just an interest payment.
Clearly, the signal is more important than the money. Even more important, the first year's signals set precedent for future years. The strongest signalling power I have is now. I will have to think on this - thank goodness I paid attention to the lecture on Spence in university. And I'm not posting conclusions on the blog either - the power of signalling improves when you don't pre-signal, and you keep your signals secret.
3 comments:
you should get ready for my ang pow! hahaha
The Squeeky One?????????
Hah. No kumquats for you then.
Humphf.
BTW, the amount of spending money one needs is not independent of current income nor situation. I'm not sure that as a net donor you are in the best position to evaluate :P
anyway, truly, the thing about ang pows it the thought that counts.. :)
Post a Comment